Edward W. Muir, President, 2023, Address delivered January 2024

AHA 2024 Annual Meeting | January 5, 2024

Presidential Address: Conversations with the Dead

Introduction: Thavolia Glymph, AHA president-elect, Duke University
Speaker: Edward W. Muir, AHA president, Northwestern University

he address explores the potential of using the metaphor of “conversations with the dead” as a historical method. Controlled by the documents, imagined conversations between the historian and the dead can capture those few moments of understanding among people, those moments when we appreciate what and who the other was. The method of conversations with the dead is not a form of proof or a demonstration of why one interpretation might be better than another. The dead do not have agency in these conversations. Only the historian does. What the dead represent is not so much their place in some historical schema as their individuality. The conceit of a conversation helps keep everyone in their proper place—the dead are dead, but the living historian has the voice, the agency, and the opportunity to reanimate the dead as an object of empathy, to give them back their humanity.